Sunday, 11 March 2012

Mergers and acquisitions success story or death trap for businesses?


Mergers and acquisitions of UK companies have decreased dramatically.  ‘UK businesses spent just £7.6bn acquiring other UK businesses in 2011, the lowest amount since 1993, according to the Office for National Statistics’.  Chris William suggests this is because of low confidence in UK companies due to increased unemployment and therefore investing in companies abroad is increasing as it is thought there will be better return on investment. (The Guardian, March 2012). For example China has seen an increase in Investment ranking fourth largest in FDI in 2011.  International Mergers and Acquisitions investment reached $822bn in October 2011.


Kellogg’s are currently running a deal to buy Pringles this year for $2.7bn.  Both these companies originate in the US.  This boosted Kellogg’s standing to world number 2 in the savoury snack market and increased share price 5% from 50.3 to 52.87 so surely this would be also beneficial to shareholders.  Kellogg’s say the deal will initially decrease profits for this year but will give savings of up to $75m a year after the first year (The guardian, February 2012)


Mergers and acquisitions were so popular in 2004 that the equivalent of one transaction was complete every 18 minutes with a total value of $1900bn.  However whilst shareholders enjoy increased wealth initially, after the first few months they often see a decline in share price.  Only 56% of acquisitions are successful against original objectives and nearly 70% of executives leave these firms within the first 5 years due to increased stress (Cartwright & Schoenberg, 2006).  One example of a complete disaster was American Lucent and the French Alcatel two telecommunications companies which merged in 2006. Since the merge the companyhas lost $7bn and lost 80% of its market value (Lafforet & Wageman, 2009). 

Some reasons for failure suggested are that it takes too long for companies to decide positions of top management and that the relationships formed are not strong enough and even in some cases the two companies may still see a divide by trying to compete against each other for the best job roles and contracts rather than work together.  To overcome this and try to make successful mergers it is suggested that integration of both companies should be done by top management as swiftly as possible by keeping staff engaged and informed and that key roles should be identified and positioned as soon as possible and conflict between the two companies needs to be kept to a minimum.  The merger of Strauss and Elite is a good example of a successful merger.  The new structure of the business was decided and implemented within 9 months.  By keeping staff informed increased confidence in new management developed and therefore motivation was high.  Two years after the merger the financial results looked impressive with both sales and gross profit increasing (Lafforet & Wageman, 2009). 

Therefore Mergers and acquisitions can be successful and not necessarily decrease shareholder value though the main aim ultimately for mergers would be to gain control and/or increase profits.  This is why we see more mergers towards financially stable countries such as the US and China as opposed to the unstable UK economy.